Saturday, June 12, 2010
Immigration and emotional impact
Immigrants flee countries of danger and violence all the time, in order to get to their goal of living in a safe place. To get to where they want to go they must go on an extremely dangerous venture. While you are on this venture you will feel many terrible emotions such as; fear, sorrow and anger. Amir and Baba left Kabul looking for safety and freedom in America. Amir, terrified for his life held on with the hope for a new beginning.
Amir was faced with many obstacles. Obstacles such as being held up at the border into Jalalabad with Baba risking his life to a Russian soldier for a woman's dignity. “Do you always have to be the hero? I thought, my heart fluttering. Can't you just let it go for once? but I knew he couldn't- it wasn't in his nature. The problem was, his nature was going to get us all killed." (Hosseini 122) Amir is terrified because his father could easily get him killed. He was also feeling very angry for his father who was risking his life for the dignity of another woman. Amir, during his trip to America had to be very brave. He was in a very dangerous situation and needed to be strong in order to survive.
Amir had to go in to a fuel tank to be taken to America. Amir's life was more at risk then rather than any other time during his journey. He had one of life's greatest gifts working against him, Oxygen. "You want to scream. You would if you could. But you have to breathe to scream. Panic" (Hosseini 128) Amir was surrounded by fear. He could not breathe, he could not see. Amir was not sure whether or not he was going to make it out alive. At this point there was no sadness or anger, but only fear.
Feelings of anguish, regret, anxiety and loss all due to one thing, Danger. Danger referring to life and death. Danger referring to loss of place. Finally danger for what is about to come ahead. Amir, terrified for his life held on with the hope for a new beginning, a good beginning.
Tuesday, June 8, 2010
The father-son relationship in Kabul
Baba and Amir had some kind of barer between them. Their characteristics were totally different. Baba sure was an admirable person but he wasn’t a great father to Amir. All Amir wanted was Baba’s attention and caring but Baba was too cold to Amir. You can tell Amir wanted Baba’s attention from following examples. When Baba’s friend came over to his house Amir asked Baba if he can sit with them but Baba said. “This is grown-ups time. Why don’t you go read one of those books of yours?” (2.5) as you can see from this line that Amir wants to join the conversation with Baba but Baba think he is too immature. There is another example, when Amir was having a kite fight. He heard the crowd yelling “Cut him! Cut him!” (7.69) and he wondered if Baba was cheering him with them. This shows how much he wants to make Baba proud on anything. After when he sees Baba smiling at him proudly when he won the kite fight.
Most different thing about these two is Baba is brave and he has to stand up for the people who are in trouble. On the other hand Amir can’t even stand up for his own friend, Hassan. This is the difference between Amir and Baba, Amir is very selfish and Baba is very generous. When Baba was trying to stop Russian soldier from raping the woman in the truck, Baba risked his life to stop that. But Amir tried to stop Baba from helping her because he thought he might actually die. Amir said. “Baba, sit down please, I think he really means to shoot you.” (10.122) But Baba refused to stop and said. “Haven’t I taught you anything?” (10.122) and he went on.
These examples show the differences between the two. Baba was wise, generous, and brave but Amir was selfish, not brave, and he was still in the process of learning. But I think that is how much Amir cared about Baba because he almost died trying to save the woman. So I think Baba should’ve been careful and thought about Amir as well.
Rahim Khan
Rahim Khan is an influential part of Amir’s life because he gives fatherly support and advice to him. He has always been there to help Amir and advise him. Amir considered Rahim Khan his first adult friend. So, obviously, Rahim played a large part in Amir’s life as a child. In fact, he has been in Amir’s life the whole time. “I am a baby in that photograph and Baba is holding me, looking tired and grim. I’m in his arms, but its Rahim Khan’s pinky my fingers are curled around,” (Hosseini, 5). Rahim Khan was also very supportive of Amir and his desires. “As always, it was Rahim Khan who rescued me. He held out his hand and favoured me with a smile that had nothing feigned about it. ‘May I have it, Amir jan? I would very much like to read it.’” (Hosseini, 31). Whenever Baba wasn’t there for Amir, Rahim Khan was.
Rahim Khan was genuinely supportive and helpful to Amir when he decided he wanted to be a writer. Rahim Khan never told him what he can and can’t do. He showed support to Amir by buying him a notebook for his stories. He was also a parental figure when he told Amir that he had to go get Sohrab to make up for what he did and to stand up for himself. “’And why you? I think we both know why it has to be you, don’t we?’” (Hosseini, 221). From these, you can infer that the main reason Amir returned to Kabul was because of Rahim Khan. He also probably took some responsibility for Amir pursuing writing. So, he was a very large influence on Amir.
Allison Thomas
Taliban's role in the novel
What is the Taliban? Webster’s dictionary defines the Taliban as “a fundamentalist Islamic militia”, which means they are basic Islamic band of soldiers. They claim to be a religious political movement, and do things because their god, Allah, would want them to. People in Afghanistan were originally very excited with the rise of the Taliban, because the Taliban initially wanted to bring back Islamic values and to make Afghanistan a better place. Soon though, the Taliban’s management slowly turned bad, and the conservative group became a problem for the Afghan people.
Kite Runner: Women's Influences- Homaira
This means, that they are ordered around by men all their lives, are treated harshly, and basically cannot be with Pashtun men. This is illustrated in the quote, ''It was me and Homaira against the world...", (Rahim Khan, 8, 99). Rahim Khan's words tell us that the entire Afghan society is against Rahim and Homaira's union, simply because culture dictates it must be so. Another valid point that Homaira's role brings up, is that even though there are these injustices and unfair discriminations, as people grow up or are growing up, they "understand" them. Rahim Khan sees what happened as an adult, and says to Amir, "Probably for the best though...she would have suffered.", (Rahim Khan, 8, 99). He says this because now that he is mature, he sees that the union would only have brought pain and sorrow. Women in Afghanistan are mistreated and misvalued, none more so than Hazara women.
Scars as a Symbol in The Kite Runner
Hassan’s emotional scar was received in his effort to stand up for what he believed was right, as he was sexually assaulted. He was challenged by Assef in his attempt to bring back Amir’s kite for him. “A loyal Hazara. Loyal as a dog.” (77, Hosseini). Hassan made a courageous and loyal sacrifice to refrain from letting Amir down. He did not give Assef Amir’s kite, and in return, he was scarred for his whole life.
Baba’s over-worked and scraped knuckles symbolize the price he paid for the courageous and loyal act of bringing Amir, his son, to America. “...I’d seen the way he winced and rubbed his wrists on damp days... ‘Besides, I didn’t bring us here for me, did I?’” (137, Hosseini). Baba left his whole life in Afghanistan to assure his son of a great, new life where he could be successful.
Finally, there is Amir’s scar that represents his loyalty to Hassan and Sohrab. With his courageous act of fighting Assef to rescue Sohrab, Amir was beaten drastically and his upper lip was sliced in two. This scar symbolizes Amir’s bravery towards sacrificing his life for Sohrab.
Hassan’s emotional scar due to his assault, Baba’s work-worn and cut-up hands, and Amir’s sliced lip due to his fight with Assef are all representations of these characters’ most courageous and loyal experiences.
Amir Needs Farrid
The effects of either being a Pashtun or a Hazara
Mitchell Lawrence-Rafaelic
Family Secrets
The first secret that the reader is made aware of occurred when Amir watched his friend/servant Hassan getting raped by the town bully named Assef. Amir felt guilty for a very long time because he didn’t do anything to stop the rape from happening at the time and he never told anybody that he saw it happen. Amir felt it was his fault that this happened because he asked Hassan to retrieve his kite so that he could win the kite running race. It was more important for Amir to have the kite retrieved by Hassan rather than to protect his friend because the kite would be proof to his father that he won the kite race. Amir desperately wanted his dad’s approval. This secret caused Amir and Hassan’s friendship to end. Amir became an insomniac and quite anti-social because he couldn’t deal with all of the guilt about this secret.
The second secret that Amir keeps from everyone was how he framed Hassan for stealing his watch and a bit of his birthday money. Amir did this because he felt guilty for not helping Hassan when he got raped. He did this because he is a coward and just wanted Hassan and Ali out of his life so he could try and forget what he did. “... and told what I hoped would be the last in a long line of shameful lies” (pg 104). This affected not only Hassan and Amir’s relationship but also Baba’s relationship with Ali and Hassan. Ali and Hassan ended up quitting their jobs as Baba’s servants and moved out. Baba was upset because he lost a true family friend and a boy he treated like a son. This also affected Amir because his guilt about this situation made him more depressed. He also was sad to see his childhood friend have to leave.
The third secret in this novel involved a family friend named Rahim Khan. He had told Amir fifteen years after Baba died that Hassan was Amir’s half brother. This affected Amir largely because he found out that his father had kept something from him, something that would have affected his decision to help Hassan when he was getting raped. If Amir had known Hassan was his half brother he would have protected Hassan from the rapist. The kite race wouldn’t have mattered because Amir wouldn’t care to impress his dad because his dad was a liar. “How could he have lied to me all those years? To Hassan? He had sat me on his lap when I was little, looked me straight in the eyes, and said, There is only one sin. And that is theft....When you tell a lie, you steal someone’s right to the truth...the things he’d stolen had been sacred: from me the right to know I had a brother, from Hassan his identity, and from Ali his honor.”(pg 225)
Secrets are kept for reasons that are sometimes unclear. The secrets that were kept in this novel shaped the future of Amir the most.
The Father-son relationship in America
Due to the major differences between Baba and Amir, Baba will try to force Amir into the thing Baba used to do as a kid, those never changed Amir. Baba continued to try to change Amir until a wise friend Rahim Khan told him “Children aren't colouring books. You don't get to fill them in with your favorite colours.” After this Baba had reduced but not completely stopped trying to change Amir.
Throughout the latter part of the book, when Baba and Amir arrive in America their relationship improves this is partly due to the fact that Baba has forgiven himself for having Hassan as his son, and that he is working hard on trying to give Amir a better life. America was very different for Baba and Amir, this passage explains the difference “For me, America was a place to bury my memories. For Baba, a place to mourn his.” (Hosseini,11,129) this just proves how Baba has given up a lot in Afghanistan for Amir and he is still experiencing the loses.
When Amir and Baba are working together at the flea market the relationship between them is very good. Baba finally sees Amir as a true man that is honourable, after all the years Baba is finally truly proud of Amir.
Kites as a Symbol
The kite shows betrayal through Hassans rape. After Hassans assault Amir never wants to see a kite again. The kite reminds him of guilt and betrayal. Not only the betrayal of a friendship, but the betrayal of brotherhood. “There were 2 things I couldn’t stop looking at: One was the blue kite resting against the wall, the other was Hassans brown corduroy pants throw on the heap of bricks.”-Amir. Through this quote it shows that Amir had a choice to make. The love of Baba or the Friendship of Hassan.
Thus, the loop ends with Sorhab. When Amir teaches Sorhab to fly kites he feels no guilt when he sees kites because of the redemption he’s done with Sorhab. Amir feels like he has saved a little part of Hassan.
Therefore in conclusion, showing that the kite represents a good symbol of betrayal and happiness in Amirs life.
Differences Between Baba and Amir on Their Trip to Peshawar.
In the book The Kite Runner, Baba and Amir experience a dangerous journey from Kabul to Pakistan, but the book makes it seem like they endured it differently. Baba was more calm, and collected while Amir was scared and nervous. “You open your mouth. Open it so wide your jaws creak. You order your lungs to draw air, NOW, you need air, need it NOW. But your airways ignore you. They collapse, tighten, squeeze, and suddenly you are breathing through a drinking straw.” (Hosseini. Pg. 129) Amir was freaking out in the fuel tank, while Baba seemed quite calm when he turned on his wristwatch. All of the smells around Amir were disgusting; and he was so thankful to be out of the fuel truck because it was such a terrible thing to endure. Except when Baba got out, he was just happy, and it seemed like nothing was wrong.
Sitting in the back of a truck for hours until you reach Jalalabad already doesn’t sound nice, but getting carsick makes it even worse. When Amir got car sick, I thought that it wasn’t only because of the bumpy roads but also the stress that it gives you. Baba on the other hand seemed not scared at all considering he stood up for a woman he barely knew. “The basement was our home for the next week and, by the third night, I discovered the source of the scratching sounds. Rats.” (Hosseini. Pg. 126) In the basement, all Amir did was worry about the rats and the smell and the surroundings, but Baba just sat and waited, a little angry by now but still calm and collected. Over all, the differences between Baba and Amir on their trip to Peshawar were very different, Amir was worried and scared, while Baba held his composure, and was calm and collective.
Knock-knock. Who's there? The Taliban. The Taliban Wh--- SHIDIGDIGDIGDIGDIGDIGDIGDIGDIG
This part comes after Amir learns that Assef is a Talib official. The Taliban obviously have immense power in Afghanistan, as Assef and the Taliban inspire fear and respect among the people of Afghanistan. We know this because we can see that they terrorize people on a regular basis to enforce their beliefs and their religion. The Afghani people and government do not fight back, or even attempt to resist in a minor form against the Taliban. As we can see from this quote the Taliban are very aggressive in their enforcement and use the most brutal forms of intimidation to terrorize the Hazaras. Having family killed in front of you can make a person very afraid. The Taliban effectively diminished any counterparts by using these methods, and are clearly the most powerful political movement in Afghanistan at that point in time.
Another example of the Taliban’s power is their ability to get what they want by bribing poor people. “There is a Talib official. He visits once every month or two. He brings cash with him, not a lot, but better than nothing at all. Usually he’ll take a girl. But not always.” ...”What choice do I have?” (Hosseini, pg. 255-256)
Assef and the Taliban inspire fear and respect among the people of Afghanistan. Zaman, who is the owner of the orphanage, explains that the Taliban official (Assef) comes and buys a child every so often. Zaman has no choice but to sell one child because in doing so, he possibly saves 10. He earns money to spend for food when he sells one child. If he does not sell the child, then Zaman risks having all the children killed or captured by the Taliban, and being killed himself.
It is truly an unfair cycle that the Taliban bring into the Afghan lifestyle. They force the children out of their childhood and into orphanages, causing them to have little food and clothing, and further leading to the selling of a child to a dangerous person. This whole cycle creates a terrible situation for not just Shi’a, but for the whole of Afghanistan, as they have no choice but to support the Taliban in their malevolent conquests in order to survive.
Immigration
Starting anew in America proved to have many challenges that Amir and Baba had to over come such as the loss of social status, riches, people, and also the challenge of adapting to a new culture. Baba and Amir's life had been one of luxury in Kabul, filled with wealth and the respected position in society that comes with it. To other immigrants from Kabul, the immigration might not have been as hard as it was on Baba and Amir, but because they went from a high social status to a very low one, Amir and Baba had that much farther to fall. Baba and Amir lost many friends and other relationships in moving to America, and again, going from an abundant amount of friends to almost none definitely would have made life harder to adapt to in America.
America was entirely different from Kabul in other perspectives as well, “the fruit was never sweet enough, the water never clean enough, and where were all the trees and open fields?” (Hosseini, 11, 133). The way America was set up and run, the difference in population, and the frequent use of technology was also something Baba and Amir had trouble grasping in their new life in America. The new culture was also something they had to adapt to, "He'd carve notches on our stick with his knife, one notch for each loaf of naan he'd pull for us from the tandoor's roaring flames. At the end of the month, my father paid him for the number of notches on the stick. That was it. No questions. No ID." (Hosseini,11, 136). In Kabul, the community was very closely knit and trusting, but in America Amir and Baba were treated much differently, this again could have had something to do with their new class/status in society that made adapting to American culture so much harder. Amir and Baba maintained some traditions from their own culture, but these traditions were used generally in the personal and private space of their home.
There were few gains in moving to America, a big one was their new found freedom and escape from the havoc taking place in Kabul at the time. The relationship between Baba and Amir was improved because both of them were able to bury there past, but the adjustment to a new country, the learning of a new language, the struggle of maintaining traditions, loss of social status, friends, and the emotional impact that went with it was a big price to pay.
A Republican Without Benefits
Taliban Power
The Taliban is a Sunni Islamist political group that controls and manipulates citizens of
There are many cases where characters from the book like Amir are affected by the Taliban’s actions. One instance is when Amir decides that he must return to
As you can see there are many ways that the Taliban control the people of
PS. Ms Kim is my favourite teacher of all time :)
Women's Roles
Soraya and Jamila Taheri represent the different roles of women in Afghanistan. When Amir arrived at their lafz, the ceremony of “giving word”, Soraya kept with tradition of not being present. When Soraya finally appeared, she was wearing a wine-coloured traditional Afghan dress with long sleeves and gold trimmings. According to tradition, Soraya’s family would have thrown the engagement party called the Shirini-khori, then an engagement period that would have lasted a few months, and finally, the wedding. “Soraya and I never went out alone together while preparations for the wedding proceeded…it was considered improper” (p. 169). But because Baba did not have long to live, they agreed they would go without the Shirini-khori.
Jamila Taheri, whom Amir called Khala Jamila, had once been famous in Kabul for her beautiful singing voice. Even though the general appreciated listening to music, he did not allow Jamila to sing in public. “He believed the performing of it is best left to those with lesser reputations” (p. 177). It had been one of the general’s conditions when they got married. Not only was she not allowed to sing in public, but she and the general slept in separate bedrooms.
Monday, June 7, 2010
Islamic Faith
Baba isn’t a very faithful Islam. Instead of following the beliefs of normal Islams, he makes up his own. An example of this is when he explains to Amir about his belief of sinning. “Now, no matter what the mullah teaches, there is only one sin, only one. And that is theft. Every other sin is a variation of theft. Do you understand that?” “When you kill a man, you steal a life, you steal his wife’s right to a husband, rob his children of a father. When you tell lie, you steal someone’s right to the truth. When you cheat, you steal the right to fairness. Do you see?” (Hosseini, page 19). Also, Baba doubts God’s existence. “If there’s a God out there, then I would hope he has more important things to attend to than my drinking scotch or eating pork.” (Hosseini, page 20). Baba’s Islamic faith doesn’t affect him much because he decides what to do. This doesn’t mean he’s a bad man. He builds orphanages and helps people around towns. “Baba always carried an extra handful of Afghani bills in his pocket just for them; I’d never seen him deny a peddler.” (Hosseini, page 259). I think this is just his act of kindness, not because of his religion. Amir’s Islamic faith affected him a little bit when he was younger. However, as he grew older, he abandoned his beliefs as he abandoned Kabul. If Amir had followed his beliefs, he wouldn’t have treated Hassan like a brother, even a friend. He would have saw Hassan as a Hazara slave, and treated him poorly. “We were kids who had learned to crawl together, and no history, ethnicity, society, or religion was going to change that either. I spent most of my first twelve years of my life playing with Hassan.” (Hosseini, page 27). Although Amir is very attached to Hassan even though he is a Shi’a, he only plays with him when it’s only the two of them alone. Also, Amir idolizes Baba and follows his footsteps. This pulls Amir away from his beliefs since Baba isn’t a very faithful Islam. Also, as Amir lived in America, he was drawn back from his religion. “Bowing my head to the ground, I recited half-forgotten verses from the Koran –verses the mullah had made us commit to memory in Kabul –and asked for kindness from a God I wasn’t sure existed.” (Hosseini, page 163). “I bow to the west. Then I remember I haven’t prayed for over fifteen years. I have long forgotten the words. But it doesn’t matter, I will utter those few words I still remember: La illaha il Allah, Muhammad u rasul ullah. There is no God but Allah and Muhammad is His messenger. I see now that Baba was wrong, there is a God, there always had been. I see Him here, in the eyes of the people in this corridor of desperation. This is the real house of God, this is where those who have lost God will find Him, not the white masjid with its bright diamond lights and towering minarets. There is a God, there has to be, and now I will pray, I will pray that He forgive that I have neglected Him all of these years, forgive that I have betrayed, lied, sinned with impunity only to turn to Him now in my hour of need, I pray that He is as merciful, benevolent, and gracious as His book says He is. I bow to the west and kiss the ground and promise that I will do zakat, I will do namaz, I will fast during Ramadan and when Ramadan has passed I will go on fasting, I will commit to memory every last word of His holy book, and I will set on a pilgrimage to that sweltering city in the desert and bow before the Ka’hah too. I will do all of this and I will think and I will think of Him every day from this day on if He only grants me this one wish: My hands are stained with Hassan’s blood; I pray God doesn’t let them get stained with the blood of his boy too.” (Hosseini, page 363-364). This shows that Amir was not a very faithful Islam but he has converted his views now. His choice of belief had impacted him greatly and his sins have haunted him throughout his whole life.
Afghanistan's Society: Ryan Yake
The Kite Runner, teaches us, young Canadians that Afghanistan was not always what the media tells us these days, but that they had a culture, markets, and most people could live a happy and prosperous life, apart from the difference between the Pastun’s and the Hazara’s.
When Assef said, "We are the true Afghans," (Hosseini 40), he was referring to the Pashtun’s because Amir was friends with Hassan, who was his servant, but more importantly a Hazara. This shows the mentality that most of the Pashtun’s posses, excluding Amir and Baba, because they try to threat Amir and Hassan with the most love they can, and treat them as one of them. The thoughts that go through the head of Assef are what some people call, insane. This mentality he has about him being better than everyone is what ruins the society of towns, cities, provinces, and countries.
The defining factor for me was when Rahim Khan said “…They don’t let you be human,” (Hosseini 209). This let me realize how poorly the Afghans were being treated by the Taliban, but more directly the women Afghans. They basically had no rights, and were treated as scum, and as if they were way lower than the male Afghans. This brought to my attention in how a couple years, such a big place, can change in such a big way, and not for the better.
The news we hear are only a bit of the story, and by reading this novel, I have transformed from an uneducated person towards Afghan society, into an expert at the topic. I thought every part was just bombs, and poverty, but I was mistaken. There is diversity, culture, markets and much more which makes it a revolutionary country.
Poor Communication
During Amir's childhood, Baba's lack of affection greatly affected him. He felt empty inside. This emptiness made Amir even resent Baba at times and got to the point where Amir even wished he had a different father. Amir said, "when they left, I sat on my bed and wished Rahim Khan had been my father." (Hosseini, page 85). That is a very hateful thought for a twelve year-old boy to have. Rahim Khan had always been more supportive and proud of Amir, which is why Amir resented his father at times.
Baba's lack of affection and communication towards Amir causes him to have low self esteem. Amir feels like he will never be able to please Baba and win his love. Amir even said, "I always felt like Baba hated me a little." (Hosseini, page 19). This causes Amir to always be second guessing himself. He spent much of his life more concerned about what Baba thought, rather than doing what his heart told him to do.
This poor communication between the father and son made Amir jealous of Hassan. Baba appeared to have a better relationship with Hassan and this made Amir upset. As a result, he never wanted to be close friends with Hassan. This inner insecurity resulted in Amir trying to show off to Hassan, whether it be through knowledge (being able to read) or wealth (his family had money and Hassan's did not). Amir was even willing to watch Hassan be raped in an effort to win Baba's love.
If Baba and Amir had been able to communicate better, things may have turned out differently for Amir. He may have been closer with Hassan and he may have had many great memories with his father. Most importantly, however, Amir may have been happier throughout his entire life.